PROGRAM SPONSORSHIP |
Formal name of the incentive and/or reward program initiative (if applicable) |
| Program name |
Pennsylvania Department of Public Welfare ACCESS Plus Provider P4P Program |
Program sponsor(s) and parent organization of sponsor(s), if applicable |
| Program sponsor(s) |
Pennsylvania Department of Public Welfare (DPW) |
Primary program contact information |
| Name |
Jennifer Basom |
| Title |
Director, Quality Management |
| Organization |
Department of Public Welfare |
| Email |
jbasom@state.pa.us |
| Phone |
717-772-6132 |
Sponsoring organization type |
| Government(s) |
| State |
| Specify |
Pennsylvania--Department of Public Welfare |
|
|
Source of funding associated with program set-up costs |
| Funding source |
| Other |
| Specify |
Funded by PA Medicaid (also receives FFP) |
|
|
Percent contributed by sponsor and grant organization |
| % Sponsor |
100% |
| Program set-up costs |
115200 |
Source of funding associated with program operations costs |
| Funding source |
| Funded by program sponsor(s) |
|
|
Percent contributed by sponsor and by grant organization |
| % Sponsor |
100% |
| Program operations cost |
172800 |
Start date & end date of the program |
| Start Date |
11/01/2005 |
| End |
"ongoing" |
PROGRAM SCOPE |
| Geographic scope of program |
Pennsylvania |
| Individuals affected by program as a percentage of total population, if known |
| Medicaid |
| (indicate %) |
100% of the ACCESS Plus population inclusive of 288,000 covered lives in 42 counties |
|
|
| Coverage of affected individuals (for purchaser sponsors only) |
| Other |
| Specify |
ACCESS Plus FFS Primary Care Case Management Program |
|
|
| Plan product(s) the program applies to (for plan sponsors only) |
| Other |
| Specify |
ACCESS Plus FFS Primary Care Case Management Program |
|
|
Direct target(s) of your program's incentives/rewards |
| Physician type |
| PCPs |
|
| Specialists |
| Indicate the specialities |
Family Practice, Internal Medicine, Obstetrics & Gynecology |
|
|
| Physician unit |
Individual physician/clinician, Medical group |
| Recruitment of program targets |
| Voluntary with no penalty for non-participation |
|
|
PROGRAM PERFORMANCE MEASURES
|
Outpatient clinical and safety measures included in the program |
| Measure sources |
| HEDIS (clinical components) |
|
| Other |
| Specify |
Appropriate prescription and patient use of chronic medications per clinical practice guidelines |
|
|
Measurement areas |
| Cardiac |
| Coronary artery disease (CAD) |
|
| Other |
| Specify |
Appropriate medication prescription and use |
|
|
| Pulmonary |
| Adult Asthma |
|
| Pediatric Asthma |
|
| Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) |
|
| Other |
| Specify |
Appropriate medication prescription and use |
|
|
| Other measurement areas |
|
Health plan performance measures |
| Performance measure weighting |
|
Consumer measures |
| Additional details about your incentive/reward performance measurement mix |
Each provider is provided with a listing of high risk patients that are part of their practice who would benefit from participation in the ACCESS Plus Disease Management Program. Providers have four opportunities to be paid for their work in support of the program: 1) Endorse and support patient enrollment; 2) Agree to supply patient contact information; 3) Completion of a “Care Coordination Feedback Form”; and 4) Appropriate prescription and patient use of chronic medications. Please see additional information on the ACCESS Plus P4P Program located at: http://www.accessplus.org/PayForPerformance.aspx |
Data Reliability
Sources of data |
| Existing or new data |
Existing data sources |
| Data type |
| Administrative in origin (derived from claims data) |
|
| Self-reported |
|
|
| Data extracting entity |
| Other |
| Specify |
Contractor and Program target |
|
|
| Data aggregator/analyzer |
| Other |
| Specify |
Contractor and Program sponsor |
|
|
| Ensures data accuracy |
Yes |
| Means of ensuring accuracy |
| Self-attestation as to accuracy |
| Specify who does the self-attestation, e.g. CEO |
Program target |
|
| Other |
| Specify |
Claims validation, defined data entry program for self-reported data |
|
|
| Risk-adjustment mechanisms used |
|
INCENTIVE/REWARD CHARACTERISTICS
|
Start date & end date of the incentive/reward |
| Start Date |
03/01/2006 |
| End Date |
"ongoing" |
Structure of the incentive or reward |
| Direct financial reward- increased payment |
|
| Upper reward limit |
1) Endorse and support patient enrollment; $200 one time payment plus $40 per contacted patient |
Scoring used to determine payment |
| Absolute goals- patient level measures |
| Pay for meeting one overall measure/group of measures |
|
|
| Other |
| Pay for reporting |
|
| Other |
| Specify |
Note: Pay for reporting (Completion of Chronic Care Feedback Form) |
|
|
| Frequency of reward or penalty |
|
| Time lag between measurement and receiving reward/penalty |
|
| Total dollar amounts awarded during the most recent calendar year |
$600,000 |
| Source of financial payments for meeting performance goals |
| New funding -internal |
|
| Other |
| Specify |
Paid through ACCESS Plus population PMPM |
|
|
COLLABORATION CHARACTERISTICS
|
| Phases of program where sought target collaboration |
| Program design and creation |
|
| Program operations |
|
|
| Characteristics of pre-implementation target feedback |
| Provider participation in program design |
|
| Cost of compliance per target group considered by sponsor |
|
|
| Receives compensation for administrative burden of data collection |
Yes |
| Characteristics of post-implementation target feedback |
| Information provided on how results will be used |
|
| Mechanism to consider additional information and communicate back to target |
|
| Process available for target to provide additional information and/or corrections |
|
|
| Blinding of performance feedback with targets |
|
| Frequency of performance feedback to the targets |
|
PROGRAM EVALUATION
|
| How the program evaluates its success |
| Improvements in clinical performance |
|
| Improvements in health status of population |
|
| Sponsor financial return on investment (ROI) |
|
|
| Evaluator |
| Program sponsor |
|
| Independent entity |
| Specify |
Contractor evaluated ROI for overall performance of the program |
|
|
| Additional results of program evaluation |
The original P4P was designed to focus more on Pay for Participation. To date, over 800 physicians have signed on to participate in the program and DPW has paid over Six Hundred Thousand Dollars ($600,000) in incentives to such enrolled providers. We are currently in the process of doing a more formal assessment of the first program year. |
| Lessons learned from designing and implementing the program |
Initially, achieving the desired level of provider participation was a challenge. We found that providers were hesitant to participate in the program due to an overall lack of understanding of the program. In addition, providers had concerns over administrative burden and payment efficiency. To assist in alleviating those concerns, provider education was provided to comprehensively detail DPW’s P4P. This education also focused on internal processes that were implemented to facilitate ease for providers in the capturing and reporting of relevant data to DPW as well as payment structure and methodology. |